N.Y.P.D. Pizza Colerain / Peachgrove Menu (2025 Update)
Welcome to N.Y.P.D. Pizza Colerain / Peachgrove, a culinary gem located at 5761 Springdale Rd, Cincinnati, OH. This vibrant establishment serves a tantalizing menu that caters to diverse palates. From their hearty salads, like the Antipasto and Grilled Chicken, to an array of flavorsome wings dressed in sauces like Mango Habanero and Garlic Parmesan, every dish shines with quality and taste.
Don't miss the hoagies; locals rave about the Spicy Chicken, especially praised by customers like James Trusty for its perfection. The Pizza Bread offers a delightful twist for pizza lovers, and each visit is punctuated by friendly service, as noted by Eric Meiners. With quick service and fresh ingredients, N.Y.P.D. Pizza Colerain / Peachgrove promises an experience that leaves you satisfied and eager for your next meal.
HOAGIES
STEAK HOAGIE
Our steak hoagie comes with your choice of pizza sauce, mushroom sauce or mayo, along with onions, pickles & our pizza cheese
FRIED CHICKEN
Two tender chicken breasts fried to perfection served with our pizza cheese, mayo, lettuce & tomato
MEATBALL HOAGIE
Meatball hoagie with pizza sauce, onions, pickles & our pizza cheese
FISH HOAGIE
Deep-fried battered Alaskan pollock served with tartar sauce, lettuce, tomato & our pizza cheese
CLASSIC ITALIAN
Most popular hoagie with salami, pepperoni, capicola, our pizza cheese, banana peppers, tomato, onions, lettuce, Italian dressing & mayo
Da GABAGOOL
For the ultimate meat lover! Packed with generous portions of pepperoni, salami & capicola, topped with onions, pickles, pizza sauce & our pizza cheese - baked to perfection
PIZZA BREAD
Hoagie bun served open face with pizza sauce, our pizza cheese & your choice of one pizza topping
GRILLED CHICKEN
Two tender chicken breasts grilled to perfection, served with pizza cheese, mayo, lettuce & tomato
SPICY CHICKEN
Two deep-fried chicken breasts tossed in spicy hot sauce served with pizza cheese, mayo, lettuce & tomato
FRIED PICKLES
We call them Frickles! With Ranch or Pizza Sauce
FAMILY SIZE CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIE
CINNABITES
Irresistible bite-sized dough bites, perfectly drizzled with butter & dusted with cinnamon sugar, served with a 3oz cup of vanilla icing for dipping delight. A sweet treat that's pure fun!
DESSERTS
BEVERAGES
PEPSI
20OZ
FRENCH FRIES
NIGHTSTICKS
NIGHTSTICKS WITH CHEESE
CHICKEN STRIPS & FRIES (4)
GARLIC BREAD
GARLIC BREAD WITH CHEESE
FRIED PICKLES (6)
CHICKEN STRIPS (9)
SIDE ITEMS
TRADITIONAL & BONELESS BITES
9 WINGS
CHOOSE YOUR SAUCE: GARLIC BUTTER, GARLIC PARMESAN, MANGO HABANERO, SWEET BBQ, BUFFALO HOT, BUFFALO MILD
12 WINGS
CHOOSE YOUR SAUCE: GARLIC BUTTER, GARLIC PARMESAN, MANGO HABANERO, SWEET BBQ, BUFFALO HOT, BUFFALO MILD
18 WINGS
CHOOSE YOUR SAUCE: GARLIC BUTTER, GARLIC PARMESAN, MANGO HABANERO, SWEET BBQ, BUFFALO HOT, BUFFALO MILD
30 WINGS
CHOOSE YOUR SAUCE: GARLIC BUTTER, GARLIC PARMESAN, MANGO HABANERO, SWEET BBQ, BUFFALO HOT, BUFFALO MILD
GARDEN SALAD
Crisp lettuce with onions, tomatoes, pizza cheese & croutons
GRILLED CHICKEN SALAD
Tender diced chicken, crisp lettuce, onions, green peppers, mushrooms, tomatoes, pizza cheese & croutons
ANTIPASTO SALAD
Crisp lettuce mixed with ham, pepperoni, black olives, onions, mushrooms, tomatoes, banana peppers, pizza cheese & croutons
VEGGIE SALAD
A salad for our vegetarian friends who want more than just a garden salad. Crisp lettuce, onions, tomato, green pepper, green olives, fresh mushrooms, croutons & pizza cheese
SALADS
OUR FAVORITE PIZZAS
STATION HOUSE
9" Pepperoni, Italian sausage, fresh mushrooms, onions & green peppers, this is our perfect blend of veggies & meats
MEATBUSTER
9" Pepperoni, Italian sausage, ham, bacon & ground beef to satisfy your meat cravings
GARDEN LOVERS
9" Fresh mushrooms, diced tomatoes, onions, green olives & green peppers come together to create a veggie lover's delight on this pizza
CRIMEBUSTER
9" This pizza has it all! Topped with pepperoni, Italian sausage, bacon, beef, ham, mushrooms, onions, green olives & green peppers
HAWAII 5-0 PIZZA
9" Our take on a classic Hawaiian pizza features chicken, pineapple, bacon, onion, jalapeno & BBQ sauce
CHICKEN ALFREDO
9" Chicken Alfredo features our grilled chicken & creamy white Alfredo sauce
PICKLE PIZZA EATER
9" Pickle lovers, this is your pizza! Choose ranch or pizza sauce, then pick your pickle level
BUFFALO CHICKEN PIZZA
9" Our take on an east coast favorite. We start with your choice of Buffalo Mild, Buffalo Hot or Hickory BBQ sauce, then we add grilled chicken, green peppers & onions
PICK 3 CALZONE
Our calzones are served with our blend of mozzarella & pizza cheese, three of your favorite pizza toppings, pizza sauce & garlic butter for dipping. Chicken & Meatball Toppings Cost Extra
CALZONES
PIZZA
PERSONAL CHEESE PIZZA
MEDIUM CHEESE PIZZA
LARGE CHEESE PIZZA
X-LARGE CHEESE PIZZA
CAULIFLOWER CRUST
10"